Skip to content

decomposer(preflight): judge a generated plan before contributors spend cycles on it #10095

Description

@JSONbored

Problem

The gate judges PRs. Nothing judges the plan. A bad backlog is discovered only after
contributors have burned effort on it, and by then the cost is already paid.

Scope

  • Pre-flight check over a generated plan, run before it is posted: criteria coverage
    (every blocking criterion mapped), issue sizing outliers, missing acceptance detail,
    dependency cycles, and orphaned issues mapping to no criterion
  • Predicted issue-quality score per issue, using the model from Epic: issue-quality measurement — score a scoped issue by how cleanly it executed #10076 — flag issues
    scoring below a floor so they are rewritten rather than posted
  • Report as a structured verdict the drafter can act on, not a pass/fail
  • Advisory in v1: it informs the human approval step rather than blocking, until its own
    accuracy is established

Acceptance

A plan with an uncovered criterion, a dependency cycle, or an issue predicted to execute
badly is flagged before posting.

Depends on

#10076 (score), #10082 (coverage).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

maintainer-onlyOwner-only work — yields no Gittensor points.

Projects

No projects

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions