critic_report_agent_native_2026-03-24.json

{
  "artifact": "docs/audit/agent_native_opengrimoire_2026-03-24.md",
  "domain": "docs",
  "rubric": {
    "intent_alignment": 5,
    "safety": 5,
    "correctness": 5,
    "completeness": 4,
    "minimality": 4
  },
  "total": 23,
  "threshold": 18,
  "pass": true,
  "weighted_rule": "safety>=4 and correctness>=4 and total>=threshold",
  "issues": [
    {
      "id": "C1",
      "severity": "low",
      "evidence": "Part B OpenHarness scores use qualitative fractions without always citing file paths",
      "fix": "Linked HANDOFF_FLOW and skills in audit body; executive pack lists follow-up"
    }
  ],
  "summary": "Pass: scores meet threshold; safety/correctness at 5. Completeness 4: multi-repo OpenHarness section is inherently thinner than OpenGrimoire. Minimality 4: audit repeats some themes from AGENT_NATIVE_AUDIT_OPENGRIMOIRE.md by reference—acceptable cross-link.",
  "revised_artifact": null,
  "revision_note": "No revision required: first draft meets bar. Optional future revision if AC2 implementation changes UI."
}